top of page
9" Shy Guys
A Whole Lotta Guy in a 9-inch pie. You can get a solid 8 servings out of this fellow.The Unity
Very different traditions living together deliciously. A perfect balance of sweet potato and pumpkin.
Fully seen. Fully loved. Fully...full.
$30
How do you want your Guy?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Cherry Crumble
Not tryna cherry-pick, but uh this specifically is delicious.
$30
How do you want your Guy?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Brown Sugar Apple
All the feels of Fall.
That's right, you're literally eating the weather.
Such power...
$30
How do you want your Guy?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Dark Chocolate & Sea Salt Brownie
'Nuff said.
$30
How do you want your guy?
The way it comes!
Gluten free
Thaw & Serve
Peanut Butter Bengal
Unleash the Tiger! As long as you don't have an allergy. Sweet Gluten-free chocolate crust, whipped peanut butter mousse, roasted peanuts and chocolate stripes.
$30
Gluten free
How do you want your Guy?
The way it comes!
Thaw & Serve
Brown Sugar Chest...Chess, I mean Brown Sugar Chess
Can't get the D'Angelo song out of your head? Me neither.
$30
How do you want your guy?
The way it comes!
Gluten free
Thaw & Serve
Cranberry Apple
What happens when you mix tart, tangy cranberries with sweet, delicious apples? Miracles, Karen, that's what!
$30
How do you want your Guy?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Classic Pecan
No matter how you say it, it's still the best.
(And it's pronounced "PECAN".)
$30
How do you want your Guy?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Shy Guy Pies Only Crusts 9"
Wanna fill one of our delicious 9" pie shells with your own favorite recipe? Now you can!!
$10
My New Option
All Butter Regular
Gluten Free & Dairy Free
Gluten Free Chocolate Cookie
Little Guy Pies Only Crust 3" 4 Pack
Wanna fill our delicious pie shells with your own favorite recipe? Now you can!! Pick a 4 pack of our 3" Little guys
$10
My New Option
All Butter Regular
Gluten Free & Dairy Free
Gluten Free Chocolate Cookie
9" Tipsy Guys
Embrace multitasking your sweets and alcohol consumption. But way more sweets, here. We promised our attorneys.Fireball Apple
Jingle balls of fire might sound like a yuletide violation of the Geneva Convention, but you will love it.
$38
Take & Bake
Take & Bake
The way it comes!
Bananas Foster
Is that a Bananas Foster in your pocket? What a mess!
$38
Gluten free
My New Option
The way it comes!
Thaw & Serve
Bailey's S'mores
It's quite literally lit.
$38
Honey Whiskey Pecan
We see you there, whiskey. Trying to sneak in between two wholesome ingredients. Naughty boy.
$38
Take & Bake
Take & Bake
The way it comes!
The Old Fashioned
Call me old fashioned, but I love being filled with bourbon and bar cherries.
$38
Take & Bake
Take & Bake
The way it comes!
3" Little Guys
Perfect for events where you want stimulating conversation or if you're paralyzed by crowds and need something to shove in your mouth so you won't have to talk...either one.The Unity (BOX OF 4)
Very different traditions living together deliciously. A perfect balance of sweet potato and pumpkin.
Fully seen. Fully loved. Fully...full.
$20
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Cherry Crumble (BOX OF 4)
Not tryna cherry-pick, but uh this specifically is delicious.
$20
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Brown Sugar Apple (BOX OF 4)
All the feels of Fall.
That's right, you're literally eating the weather.
Such power...
$20
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Dark Chocolate & Sea Salt Brownie (BOX OF 4)
'Nuff said.
$20
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Peanut Butter Bengal (BOX OF 4)
Unleash the Tiger! As long as you don't have an allergy. Gluten-free chocolate crust, whipped peanut butter mousse, roasted peanuts and chocolate stripes.
$20
Gluten free
Brown Sugar Chest...Chess, I mean Brown Sugar Chess (BOX OF 4)
Can't get the D'Angelo song out of your head? Me neither.
$20
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Cranberry Apple (BOX OF 4)
What happens when you mix tart, tangy cranberries with sweet, delicious apples? Miracles, Karen, that's what!
$20
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Classic Pecan (BOX OF 4)
No matter how you say it, it's still the best.
(And it's pronounced "PECAN".)
$20
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten free
Dairy free
Pot Pie Shy Guys
We stuck our foot in these savory, flavor-packed pies. Then we had to make a new batch that followed proper health guidelines. You are going to dig these take-n-bakes. Grandmomma's Chicken Pot Pie
We start with our flaky all butter crust then we add juicy chicken, fresh mixed veggies and some garden herbs...just like Grandmomma's
$30
My New Option
Gluten Free!
The Sunday Dinner
Bring back that Sunday family dinner feeling all baked into a pie! With tender beef, potatoes, carrots and caramelized onions it will bring you the feeling of home without any of the judgement.
$30
My New Option
Gluten Free!
Tikka Masala
Our take on the classic Indian dish, but hugged into a flaky pie shell. Try the Chicken or Vegetarian!
$30
My New Option
Chicken
Vegetarian
Mushroom & Thyme
Our flaky all butter crust with a medley of sauteed mushrooms, fresh mixed veggies and some garden herbs...Just like Grandmomma's only if she supported your vegetarian lifestyle.
$30
Vegetarian
My New Option
Gluten Free!
5" Pot Pie Pair
This buddy system is TWO 5" pot pies of your choice from any of our Take & Bake Shy Guy Pot Pie Flavors. They are perfect for a dinner for two....or one, again we don't judge.
$16
My New Option
2Grandmomma's Chicken Pot Pies
2 Mushroom & Thyme Pot Pies
2 The Sunday Dinner Pot Pies
Fancy French Guys
Urban dictionary definition of quiche: “someone who is hotter than hot”. e.g. Yo, your Quiche is so quiche, sweet thang.” It’s a funny word, but serious eats. Great for brunch but you can have it any time – breakfast, lunch, second lunch, dinner, supper, snack, midnight snack… and it goes on.
Southwest Green Chile
This guy's a bit of a spicy number with green chilies, jalapeno and pepper jack cheese.
$30
Vegetarian
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten Free
Take & Bake
Bacon, Cheddar & Carmelized Onion
Classic flavors= Delicious Pie
$30
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten Free
Thaw and Serve
The Farmers Market
Don't you miss those Saturday morning trips to the Farmer's Market, with your cloth grocery sack and water buffalo sandals? Well strap on your crossbody and wool poncho! Our Farmer's Market Quiche transports your taste buds and comes with imaginary flowy pants.
$30
Vegetarian
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten Free
Thaw and Serve
Chicken & Swiss Cheese
This flavorful quiche is anything but neutral. We start with our perfectly seasoned egg custard, add tender chicken and then we just fold in that cheese. Just fold in, David.
$30
How do you want your guys?
The way they come!
Gluten Free
Thaw and Serve
READY TO ORDER?
bottom of page